Now that both seasons have wrapped, I'd like to compare the 2 seasons and see which one did it better.
Crazy "Chaos" Caleb was the winner of Australian Survivor: Redemption. This season was excellent. All new, never-before-seen challenges and courses. Australian Survivor continues to keep the game fresh each season.
David was the new host, a former player and one of my personal favorites of all time. But as the host...it felt weird. There's no doubt the Jonathan (the former host) was the heart of the show. He was sorely missed this season.
However, this season had some excellent moments. It consisted of returning players and even some other players from over shows like Big Brother and Traitor. Other reality shows. I liked that idea. It's a pretty cool way to get interested across all your shows, putting them all on to one show.
One of the most brilliant moves was when "Dirty" Harry got duped into outing himself as a snake in front of the entire tribe by a rookie player. He knew Harry wouldn't resist a chance to "screw" the tribe, so when he pretended to go along with it, then exposed Harry in front of everyone. When it happened, even Harry had to tip his hat with respect. Brilliant move.
The show had a great cast of characters as always and the winner ended up being Caleb. A man who tried making big moves but no one took him serious and left him out of the vote the whole time. However, they all underestimated him. And when the contestants started getting voted off, his game started taking form and he ran away with it at the end.
Sure he was pretty much seen as an idiot, even I thought so at first. But he never once hid his true self from anyone. He came to play the game and make big moves. In the end, he got his way.
In the states they kicked off season 50. All returning players. Same old challenges. And the "twist" this season sucked. An Billy Eilish Idol that no one used properly and was less exciting since you couldn't play it for anyone else. A Jimmy Fallon challenge which was poorly planned out, yet oddly enough the Mr Beast challenge I enjoyed. Risking it all for big rewards or an ejection from the game. Pretty big stakes. I expect to see Devins in a Mr Beast video soon.
There were some good moments, but not memorable. The Coach/Ozzie feud fizzled out when neither of them were able to go that deep in the game. Coach rants about honor, and Joe making it to the end "without" honor because he voted Coach off, yet Coach did the exact thing to Colby a few episodes earlier.
During the live show (which was great to see again) the once again slobbered over the most overrated contestant in Survivor history Cirie by bringing her out, handing her a little trophy and showing everyone that they really wished she could've won. Puh-lease!
Then we have the winner Aubry. What an embarrassment. Someone who was on the outs the whole time. Stayed silent, kept her head down, rode on the coattails and big moves of others, claiming them for her own and getting votes other the other 2 finalist.
Don't get me wrong, the final 3 weren't my ideal choice. Out of them, Jonathan should've won only because he beat the true winner Rizzo (Riz-god) in a fire making challenge in the end. I swear, that kid annoyed me in season 49, but I came around to like him in 50. He made me change my mind on him. I started rooting for him near the end. Smarter player than I knew.
Between the 2 shows the clear winner for me was AZ Survivor. I just hope they can get another season greenlit, because I heard it's near canceling. That would be a shame. Because it's actually BETTER than the US one now and not many people outside of the states even know about it.
Survivor 51? Sure, I'll watch it. But I don't expect it to be memorable at all. Survivor here in the US, sucks.